As a fifth-grader, I was so excited to be selected to play Mammy Yokum in the school-wide production of the musical “Li’l Abner.” That is, until the popular blond child cast as Daisy Mae told me, “You got that part because you’re not very pretty, and you can’t sing.”

When I tearfully relayed the conversation to my mother, she said, “She’s a joy stealer. Don’t ever let anyone else steal your joy.”


Are you a joy stealer?

At the Dog Trainers Workshop, in addition to helping owners train their pets, we compete in the sport of obedience and teach many of our students to do so as well. Competitors are often oblivious to how the comments they make steal the joy of the winner.

“You won that class? I can’t believe it!”

“You know if my dog hadn’t laid down on the long sit stay, I would have won the class!”

“Boy, aren’t you glad Mrs. Winallthetime wasn’t here today, or you might not have won.”

I knew a boy who had been chosen to play quarterback on his middle school team, and I had the pleasure of driving him to his first game. On the way there, as I was telling him how excited I was for him, he told me his mother, an absentee parent, had called him and said, “They must not have any real football players to choose from.”

My anger and revulsion were immediate. Fortunately, after a few deep breaths I was able to explain to him what it meant to steal someone’s joy, and that we were not going to give her the power to do that.

Many years later, as a young man, he called me to say he had shared the lesson of what it means to be a joy stealer with his younger brother, who was bereft over the unfeeling remarks that someone had made when he excitedly told them where he had chosen to go to college.

Stealing joy is not always an unfeeling comment made after an accomplishment. It can be a doubt expressed, or negative response to a stated dream or goal. If you have ever told anyone that their dream or goal is “pretty lofty” for someone of their age, size, race or family background, count yourself as a joy stealer. If you are willing to destroy someone’s dream, perhaps you don’t realize that it is the joy of pursuing the dream that keeps the dreamer motivated, not simply reaching the accomplishment.

My first Labrador retriever, Ezra, had already earned his field championship, his amateur field championship, and had 65 of the necessary 100 points needed to become an obedience trial champion when a fellow competitor said to me, “No dog will ever be capable of earning field championships and an obedience championship. It can’t be done!” My jaw drops when I think about it. Isn’t it telling that I remember this attempt at stealing my joy more than I remember all the congratulatory cards and letters I received when those last 35 points were earned?

When we compete in the sport of obedience, the dogs must earn at least 170 points of the 200 points available in order to pass. Then, the top four scores in the class receive placements. Occasionally a student will sheepishly report to me that they won first place, but add that no other dog in the class received a passing score, as if somehow this diminishes their accomplishment. My response is always this: “Perhaps worse than allowing someone else to steal your joy is to steal your own. They had an opportunity to pass. This doesn’t mean you won by default, it means you won by a landslide. Celebrate!”


So how do we prevent joy stealing?

I think every single one of us has been a joy stealer, even if inadvertently. Usually it’s inadvertent. We’re often myopic and focused on ourselves – our own performances, successes and disappointments. So rather than respond to another’s successes with encouragement, we focus on our failures, sometimes from the distant past, and often from the near future.

Besides focusing on our own problems, we also find it difficult to look at the world from another’s point of view. We don’t recognize that we are saying something that might undermine another’s accomplishment.

Often, too, we crush people’s dreams out of a misplaced kindness. We don’t want them to be disappointed if they fail.

And of course, sometimes joy stealing comes from simple malice. Often, the person who is engaged in that kind of joy stealing has a long history – perhaps lifelong – of sadness and anger. Life can do that to people sometimes, because life is often hard and full of losses. So often, people try to knock others down, as they have been knocked down.

When confronted by your own tendencies towards joy stealing, focus first on the other person’s triumphs, not your own disappointments. Then go back through your own life and notice the things for which you are grateful. I guarantee that even the worst of times will include some kindness, some good people, some unexpected blessings and benefits.

If you’re the victim of joy stealers, forgive them. And then move on to the other people in your life who are confident, secure and other-focused enough to congratulate your triumphs. And be sure to be that person for them, too.

Every dream turned into a goal involves a journey laden with setbacks, disappointments and milestones. There is joy in that journey. Guard that joy well so that in the end you rightly celebrate the accomplishment as well as the memories of the trip.

Connie_headshotConnie Cleveland, a nationally recognized dog trainer, is the founder of Dog Trainers Workshop, a training and boarding center in Fountain Inn. Visit or

  1. My first Obedience Instructor called my dog “stupid” in front of our Beginners class. After getting a HIT at an all breed event with over 200 entries and finishing his UD, I ran into her at many events and no congrats or acknowledgement that a Siberian Husky could have a brain.

  2. Thank you for writing this – I only hope that some of the “joy stealers” will take it to heart. May I add – a laugh at a confided dream can be devastating and have long lasting effect. I never want to do that to anyone.

  3. What a fantastic lesson!! If we could all put that into practice, we would live in a much better world, especially in these troubled times.

  4. Thankyou for sharing.people too often steal the joy and don’t even realize they are doing it,what a shame. Life is too short we must enjoy all the joy there is particularly with our wonderful four legged partners. Smile and have a beautiful day. Brenda

  5. What a great article! I compete is performance events occasionally but mostly in conformation in the Bred-By Exhibitor class. A little over 5 years ago, I remember winning a 4 pt. major on one of my girls against 4 other “breeders” who had been showing & breeding 10-20 years longer than me. The entire entry was in the Bred-By class that day. They all “congratulated” me as we left the ring & in the next breathe I heard them say to each other “Boy that judge sure didn’t have a clue about our breed”!! I was so hurt, it was unbelievable. None of us like to lose. But at least be graceful about it. Think it if you want to but keep it inside your head. Or at least wait until you get back to your set-up, away from the winner, before voicing your opinion to the others. I have either finished or helped finish almost 50 dogs over the years so it isn’t like that day was a fluke.

  6. Great article. More than one competitor has sheepishly told me their qualifying score, embarrassed by it even tho they qualified /earned a leg toward a new title. I tell them “there us no score printed on the green ribbon. You’q’d’ so be happy as you earned it”

  7. Excellent piece and very thought provoking. I will be certain to not steal anyone else’s joy nor let them steal mine! Thanks for sharing this!

  8. It’s even worse when a judge does it. Congratulated on 1st place only to be told that if a door hadn’t opened and took another dogs attention (physically pointing to the team in question) the results could have been very different.

    My thoughts – my dog worked her socks off and was obviously the best dog on the day so deserved the win. Most other dogs on that day would have had “if only” moments so why specifically point that one out?

  9. So true! I told my daughter when she was growing up that you can always find plenty of friends who are discouraging and will feel sorry for you when something has gone wrong but it’s rare to find a friend who is sincerely happy for you when you have something to be proud of. That is a true friend!

  10. Connie is a genuine person. She loves the sport of training dogs through various competitive events. She also loves the dogs and not just the competition. I only had the pleasure of attending one of her seminars but those two days help me accomplish my goals with my dogs.

  11. Interestingly enough in October I showed my dog for his CD. When I came out of the ring on the second day of the show this person came up to me and started telling me right at the ring gate about all of the things that I did wrong. Someone asked if I took lessons from this person and I have never taken a lesson from her. I am a NADOI Instructor and have been showing dogs longer than I care to admit. I have attended your Seminars in the past but do not remember the joy stealing line. I did have a very nice score of a 199 in spite of all the mistakes she mentioned. Earlier that day a guy who was in Utility B had the same experience but he had not Qualified and this person told him it was all his fault and he flipped out and told the person to leave him alone and the person continued and he said get away from me. He told me about reading your book and the joy stealing. Love it, it is so true.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
New Orleans

How to travel like a local: New Orleans

New Orleans is not the trip to loll about a hotel room. Charge your phone, bring your walking shoes and keep your sipping hand free.
Ballroom dancing

Steppin’ out: Competitive ballroom dancing inspires four Upstate women

Dr. Anne Parker, Tammy Barber, Liz Seman and Sharon Nagy are all competitive ballroom dancers who take lessons at the Carolina Ballroom Dance Studio.

Cosmic Christmas: Robert Earl Keen’s one-of-a-kind holiday show returns to the Peace Center

Expect to hear the classic “Merry Christmas from the Family.”